When Alice V Fenstermaker was born about 1863, in Indiana, United States, her father, Jacob Fenstemaker, was 29 and her mother, Eliza Shoemaker, was 29. She married Jesse Ellsworth Ryan on 17 September 1882, in Clinton, Indiana, United States. They were the parents of at least 1 daughter. She lived in Jackson Township, Clinton, Indiana, United States in 1870 and Frankfort, Clinton, Indiana, United States in 1880. She died before 1891, at the age of 27.